Connecticut General Statutes § 53a-117c – Criminal Mischief in the 1st Degree

Overview

Criminal mischief in the 1st degree is the most serious form of criminal mischief under Connecticut law. It occurs when someone intentionally damages property belonging to another person (or to the public) under circumstances that create significant harm or risk. This statute elevates property damage from a misdemeanor to a Class D felony when certain aggravating factors are present.

These factors may include tampering with public utilities, damaging government or emergency services equipment, or causing property damage that creates a risk of serious injury to others.

Elements of the Crime the State Must Prove

To convict someone of criminal mischief in the 1st degree under § 53a-117c, the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant:

• Intentionally damaged the tangible property of another, and
• One of the following applies:
  • The damage created a risk of death or serious physical injury
  • The property was owned by a public utility or provider of public services
  • The property was used in providing public transportation, communications, or emergency services
  • The damage impaired services to the public or endangered safety

Practical Application / Rights

Cases under this statute often involve:

• Vandalism of power lines, electrical equipment, or communication systems
• Damage to emergency vehicles or fire suppression equipment
• Destroying public transit property like buses, train signals, or rail systems
• Acts of vandalism that endanger human life, such as disabling fire alarms or sprinklers

Because these acts threaten public safety and infrastructure, prosecutors treat them more aggressively than ordinary vandalism or mischief.

Related Offenses

• Connecticut General Statutes § 53a-117a – Criminal Mischief in the 2nd Degree
• Connecticut General Statutes § 53a-117b – Criminal Mischief in the 3rd Degree
• Connecticut General Statutes § 53a-116 – Criminal Mischief in the 4th Degree

Defenses

Common defense strategies include:

• Lack of intent – showing the damage was accidental, not intentional
• Ownership issues – proving the property was the defendant’s own, or that they had lawful authority to act
• No public risk – arguing that the property damaged did not actually create the risk levels required for a felony
• Insufficient proof – when the State cannot prove who caused the damage

Clarification About Arrests

Even if an officer issues a summons rather than taking you into custody, it is still considered an arrest. Because § 53a-117c is a felony, it carries much more serious long-term consequences than misdemeanor mischief charges.

Penalties

Criminal mischief in the 1st degree is a Class D felony, punishable by:

• Up to 5 years in prison
• A fine of up to $5,000
• Probation or conditional release
• Restitution to the property owner for the damage caused

Examples of Criminal Mischief in the 1st DegreeCutting Power Lines

A man intentionally cuts down live power lines during a dispute, knocking out electricity to hundreds of homes. This is criminal mischief in the 1st degree because it involves public utilities and endangers lives.

Damaging Emergency Equipment

An individual smashes the windows and slashes the tires of an ambulance, preventing paramedics from responding to an emergency. Because emergency services were interfered with, this qualifies under § 53a-117c.

Destroying Train Signal Systems

A person vandalizes a Metro-North track signal, causing train delays and creating a potential for accidents. Tampering with public transportation equipment falls under this statute.

Accidental Damage Without Intent

A construction worker accidentally breaks a water main while operating heavy machinery. Although serious damage occurs, the act was not intentional, so it does not qualify as criminal mischief in the 1st degree.

The Accelerated Rehabilitation Program (AR)

First-time offenders charged under § 53a-117c may, in some cases, be eligible for Connecticut’s Accelerated Rehabilitation Program. While eligibility can be stricter because this is a felony, judges sometimes grant AR if the damage was non-violent, the defendant has no prior record, and restitution is offered.

How AR works:

• The case is put on hold for up to 2 years under court supervision
• Defendants may be required to pay restitution, perform community service, or attend counseling
• If all conditions are met, the case is dismissed and the record erased

Frequently Asked Questions About Criminal Mischief in the 1st Degree Is This Charge Always a Felony?

Yes. Criminal mischief in the 1st degree is classified as a Class D felony.

Can I Be Charged if the Property Was Mine?

No. The statute applies only to damaging another’s property or public property.

Does Intent Really Matter?

Yes. Accidental damage is not criminal mischief — intent must be proven.

What if No One Was Hurt?

Even without injury, damaging public utilities or emergency equipment can be charged as 1st degree mischief.

Is Restitution Required?

Courts often require restitution as part of any sentence or diversion program.

Can Juveniles Face This Charge?

Yes, though cases involving minors are usually handled in juvenile court.

Does This Charge Affect Immigration Status?

Yes. A felony involving property damage and dishonesty can carry serious immigration consequences.

Can AR Erase This Felony?

Yes, if granted and successfully completed, AR will dismiss and erase the case.

Is Jail Mandatory for a First Offense?

Not necessarily. Judges may consider probation, restitution, or diversion instead of prison for first-time offenders.

What Should I Do After Being Charged?

Contact an experienced defense attorney immediately. Felony charges should never be handled alone.

Why Experience Matters

Criminal mischief in the 1st degree is far more than simple vandalism — it is a felony that can derail your career, your reputation, and your freedom. Prosecutors take these cases seriously because they involve threats to public safety and infrastructure. Having a skilled defense lawyer is the best way to protect your record and minimize the impact on your life.

Attorney Allan F. Friedman has over 30 years of experience defending clients in Connecticut courts. We know how to challenge the State’s case, negotiate alternative resolutions, and pursue dismissal through programs like AR where possible.

Call (203) 357-5555 today for a free consultation, or contact us online anytime. We are available 24/7 to help you move forward.

---